GeneralA Short Guide To The Indian Farmer Protests

A Short Guide To The Indian Farmer Protests


- Advertisment -spot_img

With 100 people missing and over 200 detained by local police, the farmer protests in India have careened out of control. Global coverage of the affair is growing as public figures share information on social media following continued bouts of violence along various highways to Delhi. The violence is an outcome of decades worth of bottled tension between farmers, and the Indian government who have regularly side-lined their interests. Understanding the growth of India’s agriculture sector is integral to deciphering the meaning behind these protests that are gradually tearing the nation apart.

India’s Green Revolution

Malnutrition in India during the 1960s incentivised the Green Revolution that transformed the nation’s agricultural sector. Irrigation, chemical fertilisers, high yielding crop varieties and pesticides were introduced to improve India’s self-reliance in the sector. Eventually, the modernisation of farming led to huge gains in the production of wheat and rice and consolidated the country’s position as the world’s second-largest exporter of grain.

The Old System

A nation-wide food marketing system was created to accommodate the rapid evolution of the sector. Before September 2020, farmers from across various Indian provinces such as Punjab, Haryana, and Karnataka, would sell their produce to wholesale markets colloquially termed ‘mandis’. Traders at mandis would then bid for these crops and sell them on to larger stores. A minimum support price (MSP) was instated to ensure a benchmark return for farmers whose livelihoods depend on these transactions.

Regardless of these measures, the pre-September 2020 system had its flaws. Traders often colluded and issued uncompetitive bids causing farmers to, more often than not, bare the financial brunt of trader conspiracy. On top of this, the production of wheat and rice now contributes to less than 20% of Indian GDP, reduced from 50% in the 1960s-70s. That and a rapidly increasing population has dwarfed the relative strength of this once lucrative sector. Farmers have therefore been urging the Indian government for decades now to implement legislation to preserve farming jobs and restore productivity.

The Big Problem

Instead of heeding these complaints, the Indian government has recently created legislation that worsens the plight of farmers already suffering from a fractured system.

In September 2020, the Indian government passed three crucial bills that have essentially enabled corporations to gain a stronger foothold in the agricultural sector and made farmers increasingly susceptible to exploitation.

  • The Farmers Produce Trade and Commerce (Promotion and Facilitation) Act – This essentially creates free, unregulated trade spaces outside the main markets where farmers originally traded. Traders looking to buy produce are therefore likely to move away from regulated trade spaces and into unregulated ones in which corporations have a monopoly, in order to avoid buying at the MSP.  
  • The Farmers (Empowerment and Protection) Agreement of Price Assurance and Farm Services – This bill creates a framework for contract farming deals. It affords little oversight, so farmers do not have much bargaining power. Since such deals happen outside wholesale markets, they could have the effect of fragmenting the market further and leaving farmers at the mercy of terms set by large corporations.
  • The Essential Commodities Amendment – This removes the storage limits previously set by the governments to control prices. Unlimited storage means wealthy players in the market can start influencing prices by stockpiling without supervision.

Overall, the three bills create two farming markets, one that is regulated and one that is not. By leveraging wealth and influence within an unregulated bubble, corporations can control the price of farmers’ products. Moving away from MSPs will inflict unlimited financial hardship on farmers who are now unable to benefit from fixed returns as corporations seek to maximise their profit margins.

The Protests

As a response to this, 250 million farmers have been marching over 360 km to Delhi in one of the largest protests in Indian history. The aim of the protest is to repeal the bills that purport to ‘modernise the Indian agriculture industry’ at the expense of farmer’s livelihood. Farmers from across the country have been setting up camp across various highways, with the intent of staying until the Prime Minister, Narendra Modi, relents and repeals. However, these protests have not been met peacefully. Thousands of security personnel and police officers have been deployed across the country to subdue the protests using tear gas, petrol bombs, metal spikes, brutal beatings, and regional internet blackouts.

Rihanna’s tweet about the farmer protests.

Renowned western celebrities such as Rihanna have spoken out about the protests, drawing criticism from Bollywood actors and actresses hedging their careers by gaslighting civilians into taking a middle ground stance.

An array of Bollywood celebrities and public figures posting suspiciously similar statements in response to Rihanna and Greta Thunberg tweets that support the Farmers Protest.

The Impact

The issue extends beyond the three bills issued by the Indian parliament in September 2020 as the Indian government’s violent response to the uproar is what is chipping away at the world’s largest ‘democracy.’

Farmer’s make up 50% of the Indian labour force yet the measures installed to protect them falls short. By relegating their interests, it is clear that either India does not care about its labour force or is under the impression that it is developed enough to modernise at the expense of agricultural workers. These changes have fundamentally jeopardised the country’s democratic foundation and has emboldened religious and socio-economic divisions in the country.

It is unclear what the situation will be like in the weeks to come as farmers remain persistent and talks between Prime Minister Modi and the protesters have proven futile. If things carry on as they are, Indian democracy and the livelihoods of Indian farmers is at extreme risk.

Hajra Tahir
Hajra Tahir
Hajra is a third-year Law with Politics student at the University of Manchester. Born in Leicester and brought up in the south, Hajra has spent four years living abroad in Saudi Arabia. She hopes to pursue a career in commercial law and is generally interested in international relations, business and the arts.

Latest news

Contributions and controversies: Kissinger, dies aged 100

Henry Kissinger, the enigmatic figure who advised 12 U.S. presidents and engaged with every Chinese leader from Mao to...

Will the Ceasefire in Israel-Gaza last?: What We Know So Far

52 days since Hamas’s devastating October 7 attack on Israel, which killed around 1,200 people, the hostage deal between...

Far-Right win big in Dutch General Election

On Thursday 23rd November, the Netherlands woke up to far-right populist candidate, Geert Wilders and his PVV party taking what...

Do Politicians deserve a second chance?

PM Rishi Sunak’s cabinet reshuffle has raised some eyebrows, not least for the sacking of controversial home secretary Suella...
- Advertisement -spot_imgspot_img

Was Braverman right about the police?

The Metropolitan Police have been called into question over how they policed both of last Saturday's protests in London. There...

This is why we need to cancel ‘cancel culture’

Universities in America are at a crossroads. In the shadow of the Israel-Hamas conflict, they’re faced with pressure from...

Must read

Contributions and controversies: Kissinger, dies aged 100

Henry Kissinger, the enigmatic figure who advised 12 U.S....

Will the Ceasefire in Israel-Gaza last?: What We Know So Far

52 days since Hamas’s devastating October 7 attack on...
- Advertisement -spot_imgspot_img

You might also likeRELATED
Recommended to you